1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Petrol Or Diesel...

Discussion in 'Lounge' started by GrumpyGolfer, Feb 6, 2026.

  1. And they have fences and bridges to preserve the wildlife. Which is very nice. :)
     
  2. Nah. The fences are to keep motorists in ! They dont want anyone getting off without paying..o_O
     
  3. Driving through France is a pleasure. Err, so long as you broadly skirt round Paris…

    Set cruise control to 80mph… aaand relax…
     
    • Like Like x 1
    • Agree Agree x 1
  4. Only today I've done a small comparison between the fuel cost of a couple of vehicles I'm considering for later this year, and it does make interesting reading for the sort of vehicle I both want and need for various activities.

    I've never purchased a new vehicle, I prefer to spend what money I have on a better quality vehicle just a few years old than buy something new that I'd consider a compromise.
    I normally buy at 2 to 3yrs old and keep for @5yrs.
    I also do almost all work on my vehicle myself so warranties don't figure so much.
    I've had my current 10yr old Discovery 4 a little longer as I don't like the Discovery 5 so much, and even now I'm unable to find an alternative that does everything the D4 does.
    But it needs changing before it starts to cost me a lot of money to keep it going.

    Simply using published MPG figures, which I know aren't real world, I like to compare the cost to cover 10K miles.
    Note that all of the options I'm considering below are Euro6 and £195/y to tax, and I can insure all for the same annual premium.

    Fuel prices based on £/l at my local Morrisons today.

    My current D4 looks like this (3.0L TDV6):
    Capture1.JPG
    So £1,463 of Diesel to do 10K miles with 600NM of Torque which is the important bit for me.

    I am considering a Discovery 5, which comes with a 3l straight 6 Diesel or Petrol tuned to different levels.
    Ignoring the D250, I'm considering the Diesel 300 and 350BHP versions or the Petrol 360BHP

    However because I don't really like the D5 as much as the D4, the option I'm actually more keen on is the full size Range Rover, mainly because it has a similar split tailgate setup to my D4 and will do everything to earn it's keep the D4 does including carting stuff about and towing big trailers.
    The 4.4TDV8 in a higher trim level would knock me back price wise to possibly 4-5yrs old rather than 2-3yrs, but having driven a couple I know how good they are.
    The 5.0 V8 Petrol is a fantastic drive, and I've run the numbers for comparison, but running one daily is out of reach.

    Note I'm not considering a Defender as they are too small and have stupid huge side opening rear doors with actually a tiny access size.

    The numbers look like this:
    The interest for this thread is the difference in fuel cost to cover 10K miles in a Discovery 5 Diesel compared to Petrol, and from my point of view the lower Torque figure of the Petrol compared not only to the D5 Diesel but my current D4
    Capture2.JPG
     
    • Useful Useful x 1
Do Not Sell My Personal Information