Petrol Or Diesel...

Discussion in 'Lounge' started by GrumpyGolfer, Feb 6, 2026.

  1. And they have fences and bridges to preserve the wildlife. Which is very nice. :)
     
  2. Nah. The fences are to keep motorists in ! They dont want anyone getting off without paying..o_O
     
  3. Driving through France is a pleasure. Err, so long as you broadly skirt round Paris…

    Set cruise control to 80mph… aaand relax…
     
    • Like Like x 1
    • Agree Agree x 1
  4. Only today I've done a small comparison between the fuel cost of a couple of vehicles I'm considering for later this year, and it does make interesting reading for the sort of vehicle I both want and need for various activities.

    I've never purchased a new vehicle, I prefer to spend what money I have on a better quality vehicle just a few years old than buy something new that I'd consider a compromise.
    I normally buy at 2 to 3yrs old and keep for @5yrs.
    I also do almost all work on my vehicle myself so warranties don't figure so much.
    I've had my current 10yr old Discovery 4 a little longer as I don't like the Discovery 5 so much, and even now I'm unable to find an alternative that does everything the D4 does.
    But it needs changing before it starts to cost me a lot of money to keep it going.

    Simply using published MPG figures, which I know aren't real world, I like to compare the cost to cover 10K miles.
    Note that all of the options I'm considering below are Euro6 and £195/y to tax, and I can insure all for the same annual premium.

    Fuel prices based on £/l at my local Morrisons today.

    My current D4 looks like this (3.0L TDV6):
    Capture1.JPG
    So £1,463 of Diesel to do 10K miles with 600NM of Torque which is the important bit for me.

    I am considering a Discovery 5, which comes with a 3l straight 6 Diesel or Petrol tuned to different levels.
    Ignoring the D250, I'm considering the Diesel 300 and 350BHP versions or the Petrol 360BHP

    However because I don't really like the D5 as much as the D4, the option I'm actually more keen on is the full size Range Rover, mainly because it has a similar split tailgate setup to my D4 and will do everything to earn it's keep the D4 does including carting stuff about and towing big trailers.
    The 4.4TDV8 in a higher trim level would knock me back price wise to possibly 4-5yrs old rather than 2-3yrs, but having driven a couple I know how good they are.
    The 5.0 V8 Petrol is a fantastic drive, and I've run the numbers for comparison, but running one daily is out of reach.

    Note I'm not considering a Defender as they are too small and have stupid huge side opening rear doors with actually a tiny access size.

    The numbers look like this:
    The interest for this thread is the difference in fuel cost to cover 10K miles in a Discovery 5 Diesel compared to Petrol, and from my point of view the lower Torque figure of the Petrol compared not only to the D5 Diesel but my current D4
    Capture2.JPG
     
    • Useful Useful x 1
Do Not Sell My Personal Information